When to Get an Attorney for a Car Accident?

August 9, 2025 | By David M. White
When to Get an Attorney for a Car Accident? When to Get an Attorney for a Car Accident

Not every car accident case requires legal representation, but many victims benefit significantly from having professional legal guidance. Anyone whose accident involves injuries, significant property damage, or disputed liability should prompt serious consideration of legal counsel. If you're unsure whether you need representation, our article on why you need a car accident lawyer can help clarify your situation.

Once you decide you need a lawyer, you face a logical question: When do I hire mine? Now. Don't wait. Every state has a statute of limitations for filing car accident cases. Your lawyer also needs to secure evidence immediately so they can build the strongest case possible.

Why You Should Hire Your Car Accident Lawyer Right After the Crash

Time is critical in personal injury cases. The sooner you secure legal representation, the better positioned your case becomes for success. Ideally, victims should consult with a car accident attorney within the first few hours or days following an accident, especially if injuries are involved.

You should not wait to speak with a lawyer if:

  • Multiple parties are involved in the crash: You should get legal representation when accidents involve several vehicles because they create complex liability issues.
  • Fault is disputed: You should hire an attorney when the other driver or their insurance company denies responsibility for the accident.
  • The other driver was uninsured: Uninsured motorists expose you to various added challenges—challenges best handled by a lawyer.
  • Commercial vehicles were involved: You should work with an attorney when trucking companies and commercial carriers are part of the accident because they have different insurance requirements and legal protections, and complex federal regulations often complicate these cases.

You should also hire a lawyer if your loved one died from accident-related injuries. As you might suspect, accidents that cause death are far more costly than others, and survivors deserve fair compensation for their economic and non-economic damages.

Some more signs that it's past time to hire a car accident attorney are:

  • Insurance companies are pressuring for quick settlements
  • Medical bills are piling up
  • Time off work is extending beyond your initial expectations
  • Insurance adjusters are requesting recorded statements
  • The other party's insurance is offering a settlement

Early legal intervention enables attorneys to build stronger cases from the outset, preserve evidence, interview witnesses while their memories are still fresh, and establish proper medical documentation protocols.

What Should I Not Do After a Car Accident?

Many well-meaning accident victims inadvertently harm their cases by taking actions that seem reasonable at the time but create headaches later.

Never do the following:

  • Accept the first settlement offer from insurers
  • Using your insurance when the other party is clearly at fault
  • Give recorded statements to insurance companies without running it by your lawyer
  • Sign any documents without your legal team looking at them
  • Accept payment for vehicle repairs from the at-fault driver's insurance before understanding the total damages
  • Admit fault
  • Delay medical treatment
  • Post about the accident on social media
  • Discuss the case with anyone except your attorney
  • Return to work, exercise, or other regular activities too quickly—this can hurt both your case and your health

These seemingly minor mistakes can result in thousands of dollars in compensation lost. Insurance companies are trained to exploit weaknesses and produce these errors, which saves the insurance company money while hurting the accident victim.

How Will a Lawyer Help With My Car Accident Case?

Personal injury attorneys bring essential skills, knowledge, and resources to accident cases that individual victims cannot match. Their involvement levels the playing field against insurance companies and ensures victims receive fair treatment throughout the legal process.

  • Investigation: Your attorney will identify all responsible parties, research applicable laws, secure evidence, and uncover additional sources of compensation you might be entitled to receive.
  • Insurance communications: Legal teams handle all calls, emails, and negotiations with insurance companies to protect clients from accepting lowball settlement offers.
  • Medical coordination: Your lawyer will work directly with your doctors to thoroughly document your injuries, learn your treatment plans, calculate current and future medical costs, and better understand what you're going through.
  • Damage calculation: Your lawyer will determine fair compensation for your medical bills, lost income, property damage, pain and suffering, and any future losses you may face. This is where empathetic attorneys are valuable, as they connect deeply with clients and account for even subtle damages.
  • Settlement negotiations: Your lawyer will present your case persuasively to insurance companies to achieve maximum compensation without having to go to trial. However, it's the insurance companies' decision whether to step up and offer fair compensation or fight your lawyer's fair demands instead.
  • Court representation: Your attorney will file any necessary lawsuits and represent you in court if insurance companies refuse to offer fair settlement amounts.

Your lawyer will be in touch, as communication is the glue that bonds the client and their attorney.

What Damages Am I Entitled to After a Car Accident?

We can place car accident-related damages into two general categories, which are:

Economic Damages

You might also think of these as "financial damages," as they can be easily understood and measured in monetary terms:

  • Medical expenses
  • Lost income and diminished earning capacity
  • Vehicle repair costs
  • Property replacement costs
  • Temporary transportation costs
  • Medications, medical equipment, home modifications, and other injury-related items

Your accident also has a non-economic cost.

Non-Economic Damages

While attorneys ultimately assign a financial value to non-economic damages, the nature of these damages is more complicated than a bill can reflect. Examples include:

These are the types of harm that entitle you to compensation. These damages will be the centerpiece of our financial demands to insurance companies.

How Do Contingency Fees Work?

One of the most significant barriers preventing accident victims from seeking legal representation is concern about attorney costs. Contingency fee arrangements address this concern by synchronizing attorney and client interests.

What Contingency Fees Cover

Contingency-based attorney fees typically cover case investigation, medical record review, expert witness consultations, settlement negotiations, court filings, and trial representation if necessary.

Benefits of Contingency Arrangements (from the Car Accident Victim's Perspective)

This fee structure provides no upfront costs, aligns the interests of attorneys and clients, reduces risk for clients, and makes legal representation accessible regardless of financial circumstances.

In other words, a contingency fee allows you to hire your car accident lawyer without putting a single dollar down.

Your Attorney Understands That You Need Compensation as Soon as Possible.

Case timelines vary significantly based on multiple factors, from injury severity to insurance company cooperation. Your lawyer will play the hand they're dealt, using their intellect, strategic savvy, and work ethic to deliver you compensation as soon as possible.

That said, several factors can affect how long a car accident case takes, including:

  • Injury severity and treatment duration. Cases involving serious injuries naturally take longer to resolve, as attorneys must wait until clients have reached maximum medical improvement before accurately valuing the claims.
  • Insurance companies' approach. Some insurers handle claims efficiently and fairly, while others employ delay tactics, hoping to pressure accident victims into accepting low settlements.
  • Medical provider assistance. Obtaining complete medical records and provider cooperation for case documentation can take weeks or months, especially with large hospital systems or busy medical practices. A lawyer's relationships with providers may be critical in avoiding such delays.
  • Expert witness requirements. Complex cases, such as those requiring accident reconstruction, medical testimony, or economic analysis, necessitate additional time for expert retention and report preparation.

When car accident cases go to trial, they take longer. It's unlikely that your case will go to court, statistically speaking, but it's a potential path to be aware of.

How Do Insurance Companies Act in Bad Faith and How Does a Lawyer Protect Me?

Until you've relied on insurance companies and been let down, you don't truly understand how opportunistic, merciless, and deceptive these companies can be. Sure, some insurance companies do things the right way, but you should never assume they will.

Insurance companies are for-profit businesses with shareholders to satisfy and bottom lines to protect. While they advertise friendly service and promise to be there when you need them, the reality for car accident victims is often starkly different.

Common Bad Faith Insurance Tactics from Auto Insurers

Some of the bad-faith strategies your attorney will protect you from are:

  • Delay tactics: Insurers can drag out investigations far longer than necessary while victims struggle with mounting medical bills. They might schedule and reschedule medical examinations and depositions to extend case timelines, fail to respond to communications or settlement demands within reasonable timeframes, and use other tactics to delay and put pressure on you.
  • Lowball settlement offers: Adjusters often make initial offers that represent only a fraction of fair compensation values, hoping financial pressure will force victims to accept inadequate amounts.
  • Denial of obviously valid claims: This tactic works particularly well against unrepresented claimants who lack the resources or knowledge to challenge wrongful denials.
  • Misrepresenting policy terms: Adjusters may misinterpret exclusions, manipulate coverage definitions, or simply misrepresent policy provisions, relying on victims' unfamiliarity with insurance contracts.

Insurers' bad-faith tactics won't be effective if you have a capable, experienced car accident lawyer.

How Attorneys Protect Against Bad Faith Tactics:

Experienced personal injury attorneys recognize bad faith behavior immediately and take prompt action to protect their clients' interests. Their involvement fundamentally changes the dynamic between accident victims and insurance companies, and your lawyer may protect you through:

  • Taking immediate control of communications: Once legal representation is established, all insurance communications go through the attorney's office, preventing adjusters from using pressure tactics, making misleading statements, or securing damaging admissions from accident victims.
  • Holding insurers accountable: Lawyers ensure that all insurance communications are documented, deadlines are tracked, and instances of bad faith behavior are accurately recorded for potential use in litigation. This documentation often proves key in demonstrating patterns of bad faith conduct.
  • Exercising their legal leverage: A lawyer's ability to sue can significantly alter insurance companies' behavior. Adjusters who might ignore or mistreat unrepresented claimants typically respond much more professionally when dealing with attorneys who have the knowledge and resources to file lawsuits.
  • Critically assessing all settlement offers: Attorneys provide objective evaluation of settlement offers, ensuring that clients understand whether proposed amounts represent fair compensation or bad-faith lowball tactics.
  • Protecting you through bad-faith lawsuits: When insurance companies engage in particularly egregious bad-faith conduct, attorneys can file separate lawsuits seeking damages beyond the original accident claim. Bad faith lawsuits can also serve as a protection for claimants, as the potential for filing a suit can motivate insurance companies to act ethically.

The hope is that liable parties will pay you what you deserve without a fight. The likelihood of this? Not great.

Hiring a lawyer ensures you won't be affected by even the most aggressive bad-faith tactics.

Make Recovery and Peace of Mind Your Mission

Having a lawyer on top of your case will allow you to:

  • Prioritize rest and sleep: Allow your body adequate time to heal by getting 7-9 hours of quality sleep and taking breaks throughout the day.
  • Follow all medical treatment religiously: Attend every appointment, complete physical therapy sessions, and take medications as prescribed for optimal recovery.
  • Manage stress and emotional healing: Consider counseling or therapy to process trauma, practice relaxation techniques, and lean on family and friends for support.
  • Focus on nutrition and hydration: Eat nutrient-rich foods that support healing and stay well-hydrated to aid your body's recovery process.
  • Create a calm environment: Minimize stressful situations, avoid overwhelming activities, and permit yourself to say no to non-essential commitments.

You have the most control over your health, along with your doctors. You owe it to yourself to focus on healing. Trust your legal team to resolve your case successfully.

Hiring Your Car Accident Attorney Must Be a Priority

Remember that insurance companies have one primary goal: minimizing claim payouts to protect their profits. Accident victims need advocates who prioritize their recovery and financial protection. Qualified personal injury attorneys provide this essential service, fighting for fair compensation while clients focus on healing and rebuilding their lives.

If you've suffered an injury in a car accident, don't face the insurance system alone. Consult with an experienced personal injury attorney to understand your rights, protect your interests, and pursue the compensation you deserve. Your future recovery and financial stability may depend on your decisions in the immediate aftermath of your accident. For more information about how fault is determined in accidents, read our guide on understanding comparative fault, or contact us today for a free consultation.

Visit our homepage to learn more about our legal services.

David M. White Author Image

David M. White

Attorney

David M. White is an attorney with offices in Abilene and San Angelo, Texas. His practice is focused on Personal Injury cases and Criminal Defense. Mr. White attended Texas Tech University where he earned a B.B.A. in Finance in Honors Studies in 2002, graduating magna cum laude. He received his Doctor of Jurisprudence from the Texas Tech University School of Law in 2006.

If you, a friend, or family member need legal advice, please feel free to contact our firm for a free consultation with David White, a Personal Injury attorney in Abilene, Texas.

Author's Bio